Why streaks backfire: the "what the hell" effect after a missed day

You have done the thing 23 days in a row. Day 24 goes wrong: a late train, a sick child, a long dinner. The next morning the habit feels pointless, and by the weekend it has stopped. One missed day cannot explain that on its own. The explanation is in how people react when they break a rule they set for themselves.
The diet study behind the pattern
In 1975 Peter Herman and Deborah Mack compared two groups of people of normal weight: chronic dieters (high “restraint”) and people who did not restrict their eating. Everyone first ate a “preload” of varying size, and then the researchers measured how much they ate next.
Non-dieters behaved as you would expect: the bigger the preload, the less they ate afterwards. Dieters did the opposite. The more they had already eaten, the more they ate next. (Herman and Mack, 1975)
Once the day’s diet was broken, there was no rule left to protect, so the restraint switched off. Psychologists later gave this a blunt name, the “what the hell” effect. It is not about food. Any all-or-nothing rule has the same weak point: the first exception makes the rule look already lost.
A streak counter is the same kind of rule
A streak is a rule with a number attached: every day, no exceptions. Jackie Silverman and Alixandra Barasch tested what that number does to behaviour.
In a 30-day workplace walking challenge with 980 employees, people who had met the 7,000-step goal at least three days running were more likely to meet it again the next day. People whose streak had just broken were clearly less likely to, even after accounting for how often each person met the goal overall.
Field data like that cannot separate the streak from the person, so they also ran experiments in which everyone did exactly the same work and only the log changed. In one, all participants completed four exercises, but for some the app’s log showed a gap. Of those with an intact log, 66% chose to do another strength exercise; of those whose log showed a break, 58% did. In a language task the gap was larger: 78% against 53%. The behaviour was identical. Only the record of it differed.
Two further results matter for anyone tracking a habit:
- The drop was larger when people blamed the break on themselves rather than on something outside their control.
- When people were told a broken streak could be repaired, most of the drop went away: 85% carried on, against 69% with a plain broken streak and 93% with an intact one.
So a streak counter helps while it is running and works against you at the exact moment you most need help.
What one missed day actually costs
In habit terms, very little. In Lally’s 2010 study of habit formation, missing a single opportunity did not materially change how automatic the behaviour became. (Lally et al., 2010) We covered that study in How long does it really take to form a habit? Nearly all the cost of a missed day is in what you conclude from it.
Build the slack in before you need it
Marissa Sharif and Suzanne Shu studied a simple fix they call an emergency reserve: a small number of allowed skips, defined in advance, that you would rather not use. In their 2017 paper people preferred goals with a reserve over other goal types and persisted longer with them, in part because they wanted to avoid spending the reserve. (Sharif and Shu, 2017)
A later paper, with one field study and four lab studies, looked at the moment right after a failure. People whose goals had emergency reserves felt they were still making progress, stayed more committed to the goal and were more likely to keep going than people with equivalent goals that had no slack. (Sharif and Shu, 2021)
A reserve is different from lowering the bar. The 2021 comparison was against objectively equivalent goals without slack, so the benefit came from how the goal was framed, not from asking less. Keep the goal ambitious, keep the skips few, and make using one feel like spending something you would rather keep.
How to set up a streak that survives a bad day
1. Write the reserve into the rule. For example: “every day, with two emergency skips a week, and unused skips do not carry over.” A skipped day then follows the plan instead of breaking it.
2. Name the outside reasons in advance. Illness, travel, a family emergency. Because self-blame made the drop worse, deciding ahead of time what counts as an external break keeps a sick day from turning into evidence that you lack discipline.
3. Track the rate, not only the run. “26 of the last 30 days” survives a bad Tuesday. “Day 0” does not, even though the habit behind both numbers is almost the same.
4. Make the next day the repair. A rule such as “never miss twice” gives a missed day a defined end. The repairable streak result suggests that knowing how to get back on track removes much of the damage.
5. Use a fresh start after a longer lapse. Hengchen Dai, Katherine Milkman and Jason Riis found that Google searches for “diet”, gym visits and goal commitments all rise after temporal landmarks such as the start of a week, a month or a birthday. Those landmarks put past slips into a closed chapter. If a week has gone by, pick the next Monday and start again on purpose. (Dai, Milkman and Riis, 2014)
If you use a tracker
Look at what it shows on the day after a miss. A single number that drops to zero is the setup the research warns about. We built Habit Observer around a history of cells instead of one counter: a missed day is one empty cell in a mostly full month, and the month still looks like what it was.
Sources
- Herman, C. P., and Mack, D. (1975). Restrained and unrestrained eating. Journal of Personality, 43(4), 647-660.
- Silverman, J., and Barasch, A. (2023). On or off track: How (broken) streaks affect consumer decisions. Journal of Consumer Research, 49(6), 1095-1117.
- Lally, P., van Jaarsveld, C. H. M., Potts, H. W. W., and Wardle, J. (2010). How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology, 40(6), 998-1009.
- Sharif, M. A., and Shu, S. B. (2017). The benefits of emergency reserves: Greater preference and persistence for goals that have slack with a cost. Journal of Marketing Research, 54(3), 495-509.
- Sharif, M. A., and Shu, S. B. (2021). Nudging persistence after failure through emergency reserves. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 163, 17-29.
- Dai, H., Milkman, K. L., and Riis, J. (2014). The fresh start effect: Temporal landmarks motivate aspirational behavior. Management Science, 60(10), 2563-2582.